Unlock the Editor’s Digest without spending a dime
Roula Khalaf, Editor of the FT, selects her favorite tales on this weekly e-newsletter.
Indonesia is flooding the worldwide nickel market with low-cost provides, forcing rivals to close unprofitable mines and sowing panic in Washington and Paris that the upheaval will give China extra management over the strategic useful resource.
The nation, the world’s largest producer, expanded manufacturing by 30 per cent final yr to 1.9mn tonnes though international demand for the metallic utilized in electrical automobile batteries and chrome steel barely grew, in accordance with funding financial institution Macquarie.
Indonesia’s aggressive push has helped enhance its market share to 55 per cent final yr, up from simply 16 per cent in 2017. Nonetheless the elevated output additionally contributed to a 43 per cent fall within the international value of nickel prior to now yr.
Merchants and analysts concern that Indonesia’s dominance of worldwide provide will solely develop because the metallic’s low value forces producers elsewhere to shut unviable mines and put the brakes on new developments.
“If we see numerous non-Indonesia tasks go to the wall, then Indonesia’s share goes even increased,” mentioned Jim Lennon, a veteran nickel market analyst at Macquarie. “In the meanwhile, there is no such thing as a different. There is no such thing as a huge supply being developed or accepted elsewhere.”
Chinese language corporations made large investments in Indonesian nickel to safe low-cost inputs for his or her chrome steel and to fulfill the anticipated surge in demand for electrical automobile batteries.
The availability of business metals similar to copper, lead and zinc is often 0-2 per cent above or beneath annual demand. However nickel’s provide was about 6-8 per cent above final yr’s 3.2mn tonnes of consumption due to Indonesia’s provide increase, mentioned Lennon.
Nonetheless client and industrial demand from China has waned. The tepid financial restoration from Beijing’s lengthy zero-Covid coverage has curbed gross sales of electrical autos. China has additionally been shifting to decrease value batteries freed from nickel and cobalt, which means nickel demand final yr was largely supported by the metal trade.
The dual forces of elevated provide and weaker demand has pushed the nickel value on the LME to about $16,500 a tonne prior to now yr. Lennon estimated that present ranges made greater than half of worldwide nickel manufacturing uneconomic.
Nickel producers in western Australian, one of many world’s largest producing areas, have had a tricky January. Billionaire Andrew Forrest mentioned his group Wyloo Metals would shut its nickel mines there and BHP warned that it was “evaluating choices” round Nickel West.
Australian miner IGO mentioned it could write off the worth of the Cosmos nickel mine it solely acquired 18 months in the past and First Quantum will halt mining at its Ravensthorpe web site for 2 years.
The potential closure of unprofitable mines has set off alarm bells in western capitals of an extreme focus of provide in Indonesia, the place nearly all of mines, processing websites and provide offers are managed by Chinese language teams.
Chinese language corporations have additionally gained a technological edge in nickel processing and conversion expertise, whereas additionally dominating international steelmaking and battery manufacturing, making it tougher for potential consumers elsewhere to compete.
Ashley Zumwalt-Forbes, deputy director for batteries and important supplies on the US Division of Power, wrote on social media that Indonesian and Chinese language market dominance was an “excessive menace” to nationwide and worldwide safety, in addition to the atmosphere.
“It’s Darwinian right this moment. Folks must die,” mentioned one nickel dealer. “Western governments must both subsidise lossmaking operations, incentivise new low-cost operations in Indonesia and different locations or depend upon the Chinese language. All the governments are saying the final one is untenable however haven’t bought their head across the first two.”
Australian assets minister Madeleine King known as over the weekend for consumers to pay a premium for extra sustainable nickel to degree the enjoying area with Indonesia for its producers.
In latest weeks French authorities delegations have been visiting New Caledonia, as soon as a globally necessary nickel manufacturing hub, as they grappled with how a lot help to increase the French Pacific island territory’s three massive mine operators after every of them vowed to cease placing money into lossmaking operations.
A senior Indonesian nickel govt mentioned that whereas margins have been turning into skinny for native producers, they have been hopeful of surviving the downturn longer than opponents in different elements of the world due to their low prices.
Consequently, analysts mentioned that nickel producers outdoors of Indonesia confronted extra ache.
“We haven’t seen sufficient cuts but to say we’ve hit a flooring,” mentioned Colin Hamilton, commodities analyst at BMO in London.
Extra reporting by Nic Fildes in Sydney
